Darren Kinnard/River Radio Sports Central
BLOOMINGTON — A proposed amendment to the IHSA by-laws that would’ve changed football from the current format to districts has failed.
For the past two weeks, IHSA member schools have voted on 14 amendments, 12 of which passed. Schools could vote yes, no, or no opinion with a simple majority needed to pass. The district proposal received 379 no votes, 272 yes votes, and 76 no opinions.
727 of the 815 member schools voted. The 89.2% vote was the largest turnout in the last 13 years the IHSA has posted results.
A district proposal narrowly passed in 2018, but a year later was rescinded, also by a narrow vote. If it would have passed, this year’s district proposal would’ve gone into effect immediately, starting with the 2024 season. Even schools that were in favor of the move to districts worried about the accelerated timeline as well as a lack of firm answers for structural questions.
“The IHSA Board of Directors has already had discussions about the potential of forming a Football Ad Hoc Committee in 2024 in the event that this district proposal failed to pass,” said IHSA Executive Director Craig Anderson. “They want to be proactive in trying to address the issues that are at the root of different football proposals seemingly being brought forth each year. They recognize the myriad issues in IHSA football are unique and can be based on geography, school size, conference affiliation, and the traditional success of a program, which is why no recent proposals have garnered enough support to pass. There is likely no singular answer to these issues, but the Board wants to explore the idea that a large and diverse group from around the state might be able to find some solutions that the high school football community in the state would support.”
The other proposal that did not pass was one that would’ve cut summer contact days from 25-18. That vote was 407 no, 302 yes, and 18 no opinion.
Here is the full list of proposals and results:
Proposal 4 (Passes 578-124-24) Allows coaches to conduct out of season strength and conditioning workouts with limits of no more than 4 days per week and no more than 90 minutes per session outside the season. No coaching of the skills of a sport during any session.
Proposal 5 (Passes 449-233-45): Allows students to meet the residence by-law when their parent/guardian is a full-time staff member at a public school whose attendance boundary they do not reside in if the district has a Board Policy permitting students of employees to attend tuition free.
Proposal 9 (Passes 547-136-43): Modifies the All-Star games participation limit to include all sports as opposed to just basketball, football, soccer and volleyball.
Proposal 11 (Fails 302-407-18): Modifies the number of summer contact days restriction from 25 to 18 days.
Proposal 12 (Passes 566-132-23): Allows coaches to conduct strength and conditioning workouts with limits of no more than 4 days per week and no more than 90 minutes per session during the summer contact days. Conditioning training does not count against the summer contact day count. No coaching of the skills of a sport during any session in order for the session not to count as a summer contact day.
Proposal 14 (Passes 422-136-166): Restricts a Pre-Contest Physical Examination from determining a student’s eligibility for a contest other than in sports that require weigh-ins or sports-specific nail or skin checks.
Proposal 15 (Passes 564-36-118): Modifies the participation under an assumed name to match the language passed two years ago in By-law 3.090.
Proposal 16 (Passes 540-126-54): Eliminates the IHSA Tournament Limitations By-law (5.004).
Proposal 17 (Passes 410-232-85): Creates the opportunity for football teams to conduct a pre-season scrimmage with another school. Specific scrimmage limitations include the following: Use of IHSA Officials, 4 separate 12 play segments, no special teams, 48 total play limits per player, no live contact or thud in practice the day before or after the scrimmage. Scrimmage to be held on Friday or Saturday of IHSA Week 7. Players are eligible to participate in the scrimmage after participating in 8 different days of practice.
Proposal 18 (Fails 272-379-76): Establishes districts in the sport of football to be determined by the IHSA using geography and classification. Eight districts in each class with eight schools in each district. District games in weeks 3 – 9 of the regular season. Top 4 schools in each district qualify for the IHSA Play-offs. Seeding procedures will be similar to current seeding procedures with teams from the same district not to play in the first round.
Proposal 19 (Passes 352-48-321): Eliminates the Boys Gymnastics season and contest limitation by-law.
Proposal 20 (Passes 541-134-48): Eliminate the match limit per tournament language in girls and boys volleyball.
Proposal 22 (Passes 594-18-111): Increase the number of girls’ wrestling team contests from 18 to 25.
Proposal 23 (Passes 464-82-181): Establishes a Girls Flag Football fall season limitation (Monday of Wk. 6 to Saturday of Wk. 21), a pre-season practice requirement of 9 practices before a contest and a regular season contests limitation of 25 games exclusive of the IHSA State Series.
